Representative category image — not a photograph of this specific business.
Photo: Kaszeta (Wikimedia Commons contributor) (Public domain)
Redhead Bay Café
Virginia Beach · Creeds area
Bakery & café, American · Casual
A breakfast, brunch, and lunch café in Creeds, opened in 2019 by the same family that owns the longstanding Blue Pete's Restaurant, in the building of the former Creeds Café.
- Local favorite
Most recently checked: Aug 2026 — see exactly what was checked below.
Restaurant hours, menus, and reservation systems change often — confirm current hours with the restaurant directly before visiting.
Food and place
Sourced cultural or food-origin context connecting this listing to the wider Pungo, Creeds & Red Mill guide.
The Creeds Gunning Club, and decoys carved locally
Documented historyPart of a broader regional traditionLike Pungo, Creeds had its own historic waterfowl-hunting club — the Creeds Gunning Club, one of the roughly 100 clubs that once ringed Back Bay and Currituck Sound, per the same 1997 Virginian-Pilot account. Redhead Bay Café's own dining room, in Creeds, carries this heritage forward directly: it displays carved decoys by local artisans and vintage maps of the Back Bay region, per Coastal Virginia Magazine's feature on the café.
Sources & more detail
- Source: The Virginian-Pilot (1997, archived) — "The Guns of Autumn Are Falling Silent" (checked Aug 2026)
- Source: Coastal Virginia Magazine — "Redhead Bay Café Brings Brunch to Pungo" (checked Aug 2026)
Verification
Each fact below is checked and dated independently — a status here covers only that specific field, never the whole listing.
- operatingStatus verified — Redhead Bay Café (official site), checked Aug 2026
Confirmed by successfully retrieving the restaurant's own site describing current hours on 2026-08-09.
- Source: Redhead Bay Café (official site) (checked Aug 2026)
- identity verified — Redhead Bay Café (official site), checked Aug 2026
- Source: Redhead Bay Café (official site) (checked Aug 2026)
- Source: Coastal Virginia Magazine — "Redhead Bay Café Brings Brunch to Pungo" (checked Aug 2026)
- address verified — Redhead Bay Café (official site), checked Aug 2026
- Source: Redhead Bay Café (official site) (checked Aug 2026)
- Source: Coastal Virginia Magazine — "Redhead Bay Café Brings Brunch to Pungo" (checked Aug 2026)
- coordinates verified — OpenStreetMap Nominatim geocoder — Redhead Bay Cafe, checked Aug 2026
Address-geocoded via OpenStreetMap Nominatim; the top result independently resolved to a business-named POI for this café.
- Source: OpenStreetMap Nominatim geocoder — Redhead Bay Cafe (checked Aug 2026)
- communityArea verified — 13News Now — "The owners of Blue Pete's Restaurant are turning Creeds Cafe into Redhead Bay Cafe", checked Aug 2026
Genuinely mixed sourcing, disclosed rather than picked silently: the café occupies the former "Creeds Café" building, a 13News Now headline frames the location as "Creeds," and the geocoder's own independent place hierarchy names "Creeds, Virginia Beach" for this exact address. Coastal Virginia Magazine's feature on this same café instead describes it as being "in the Pungo neighborhood" — that description is not discarded, just outweighed by three converging sources for Creeds. Recorded as Creeds area on the weight of evidence, not as a certainty beyond dispute.
- Source: 13News Now — "The owners of Blue Pete's Restaurant are turning Creeds Cafe into Redhead Bay Cafe" (checked Aug 2026)
- Source: OpenStreetMap Nominatim geocoder — Redhead Bay Cafe (checked Aug 2026)
- familyOwned verified — Redhead Bay Café (official site), checked Aug 2026
Opened by Aristotle Cleanthes (with brother Nicholas), the same family that has owned Blue Pete's Restaurant since 2011.
- Source: Redhead Bay Café (official site) (checked Aug 2026)
- Source: Coastal Virginia Magazine — "Redhead Bay Café Brings Brunch to Pungo" (checked Aug 2026)
- localFavoriteRecognition verified — Coastal Virginia Magazine — "Redhead Bay Café Brings Brunch to Pungo", checked Aug 2026
Two independent, dedicated local/regional food-journalism features, not a popularity ranking or an opening-announcement blurb alone.
- Source: Coastal Virginia Magazine — "Redhead Bay Café Brings Brunch to Pungo" (checked Aug 2026)
- Source: 13News Now — "Friday Flavor: Redhead Bay Cafe" (checked Aug 2026)
- localSourcing: not confirmed
No sourcing claim found on the café's own site or in the Coastal Virginia Magazine feature — left unconfirmed rather than inferred from its rural setting or waterfowl-themed décor.
See something out of date? Report a correction.
Harvest & Harbor is a free, independently researched project from Empower AI Labs. If this page helped you, support continued local research on Patreon (opens in a new tab).